Pre-Seed Secrets: What Investors Really Look for (It’s Not Your Pitch Deck!)

Making BillionsPre-Seed SecretsJan 26, 202625 min

Pre-seed investor Adam Jones reveals why the startup funding playbook is broken, arguing that industry experience and founder-market fit matter far more than polished presentations. He makes the case that generational founders with deep domain knowledge and speed to conviction are what separate viable investments from tourist ventures in today's competitive landscape.

Key takeaways

•Industry experience trumps everything—investors prioritize founders who have unique domain knowledge over those with perfect pitch decks.
•Speed to conviction gives founders a decisive edge when everyone can build something, knowing what to build faster than competitors matters most.
•Investors separate 'tourists from titans' by identifying generational founders building mass-scale solutions rather than incremental improvements.
•Successful pre-seed investing requires building belief systems around teams despite incomplete information—it's about playing the game with what you have.

Listen to full episode

0:00

Best moment

1:33· 39s

1:33 / 2:12

Yeah. What we look for is, what's the founders' unique edge in what they're building? Industry experience for us is absolutely paramount. We ultimately want to know what does this founder know about their market that the rest of the world just doesn't understand. And it's that specific knowledge that we think is going to make their approach super sticky. They're going to be really, really compelling to customers that are going to get out there way faster than everybody else. Joe Carlasare (zero fifty seven:thirty seven): Brilliant.

So how does that help you when now that you're looking at founders, what does that do as far as creating a shortlist or how much weight do you put on what you discover

from this? Joe Kutner

Full clip page →

“It's almost always defined by a long career, a long exposure as some inherited knowledge of being in or around that space, of growing up in that space in a way that nobody else really can.”
at 2:21